| A1 | –Lincoln Center Theater Orchestra | Overture | 4:43 |
| A2 | –Lincoln Center Theatre Chorus | Cotton Blossom | 1:45 |
| A3 | –Barbara Cook, Stephen Douglass | Make Believe | 4:49 |
| A4 | –William Warfield, Lincoln Center Theatre Chorus | Ol' Man River | 2:45 |
| A5 | –Constance Towers (2), Rosetta LeNoire, William Warfield, Lincoln Center Theatre Chorus | Can't Help Lovin' Dat Man | 4:28 |
| A6 | –Allyn Ann McLerie, Lincoln Center Theatre Chorus | Life Upon The Wicked Stage | 3:33 |
| B1 | –Barbara Cook, Stephen Douglass, David Wayne (3), Lincoln Center Theatre Chorus | You Are Love | 4:59 |
| B2 | –Lincoln Center Theatre Chorus | At The Chicago World's Fair (Opening Act Ii) | 1:37 |
| B3 | –Barbara Cook, Stephen Douglass, David Wayne (3), Lincoln Center Theatre Chorus | Why Do I Love You? | 4:15 |
| B4 | –Constance Towers (2) | Bill | 4:27 |
| B5 | –Allyn Ann McLerie, Eddie Phillips | Good Bye My Lady Love | 2:01 |
| B6 | –Barbara Cook, Lincoln Center Theatre Chorus | After The Ball | 2:22 |
| B7 | –William Warfield, Lincoln Center Theatre Chorus | Finale: Ol' Man River | 2:08 |
